Slow-cooked lamb shank
Port of Leith tawny wine, rosemary and tomato sauce; choice of mash included.
GBP 22.00 per item

Edinburgh, United Kingdom
Scottish · $$–$$$
Hours
Daily from 12:00; last food orders at 20:30.
Last food orders are at 20:30. Closed 24, 25 and 26 December.
Check availability below.
Confirm current hours, menu and reservation availability before visiting.
Check availabilityPort of Leith tawny wine, rosemary and tomato sauce; choice of mash included.
GBP 22.00 per item
Thistly Cross apple-cider sauce; choice of mash included.
GBP 22.00 per item
Heather honey, turnip purée and whisky-peppercorn cream sauce; choice of mash included.
GBP 22.00 per item
Horseradish gravy; choice of mash included.
GBP 22.00 per item
Spatchcock chicken with whisky-peppercorn sauce; choice of mash included.
GBP 22.00 per item
Vegetarian dish that can be made vegan; contains chestnuts. Choice of mash included.
GBP 20.00 per item
Caramelised onion gravy; can be made vegan. Choice of mash included.
GBP 20.00 per item
Scotch bonnet chilli and whisky cream sauce; vegetarian, contains egg. Choice of mash included.
GBP 20.00 per item
Tarragon sauce and chestnut crumble; can be made vegan. Choice of mash included.
GBP 20.00 per item
Free-range egg with pork and gluten-free panko breadcrumbs; shared-kitchen caveat applies.
GBP 8.50 per item
Taster with mash, turnip and peppercorn sauce; meat, vegetarian or vegan versions.
GBP 11.00 per item
Butterscotch sauce and vanilla ice cream; may contain traces of nuts.
GBP 8.00 per item
Cream, raspberries, whisky, honey and oats.
GBP 7.50 per item
Can be made vegan on request.
GBP 7.00 per item
Makars Mash Bar serves Scottish comfort food on Bank Street, beside the Mound in central Edinburgh. Each main comes with a choice of mashed potatoes. The mash can include mature Scottish cheddar, wholegrain mustard or other flavours. Slow-cooked lamb shank, beef shoulder and homemade haggis are central to the menu. Lentil sausage and mushroom dishes give the menu a plant-based side. The restaurant also grows its own speciality mushrooms. Small dining rooms, exposed stone and wooden tables create a relaxed setting. Two nearby doors belong to the same restaurant, with the same food and atmosphere. Groups are limited to eight guests.
Please notify the restaurant if you cannot attend.
Book only through the official website link; reservations open exactly 30 days ahead, to the minute. Maximum group size 8. More than half of the seating is reserved for walk-ins. Door 1 is for bookings and Door 2 for walk-ins. Join the waitlist in person; return within 10 minutes when called. The waitlist closes at a 90-minute wait and may close early in the evening.
Indoor seating
Indoor dining rooms; separate doors for bookings and walk-ins.
Outdoor seating
Small terrace, described by the operator for summer visits.
Pets allowed
Dogs are welcome on the terrace in summer, but are not allowed inside.
Available
Vegetarian haggis, lentil sausage and mushroom dishes are listed.
On request
Several mains can be made vegan; request the vegan preparation and suitable mash. Olive-oil mash has limited availability.
Available
Dairy-free olive-oil mash is listed with limited availability. Ask staff which main and sauce suit your needs.
Available
Many dishes use or can use gluten-free ingredients, but there is one shared kitchen with possible cross-contamination. Inform staff. Black-pudding mash contains oats not marked gluten-free.
Not available
The operator states that its meat is not halal; plant-based alternatives are offered.
Discuss allergens and cross-contact with the restaurant.
Louna Stone
Louna Stone describes warm, helpful service and a bright, rustic dining room. She particularly enjoyed vegan haggis with olive-oil mash and rich onion gravy, followed by vegan fruit crumble. Her companion also enjoyed the lamb shank. This account reflects an earlier visit and menu.
Read original reviewParaphrased independent personal food review, published 26 February 2022; no numerical rating given.
Harden's
Harden's 2026 survey praises the restaurant's hearty Scottish cooking, varied mash and good value. It highlights homemade haggis and the mushroom-growing project. The guide rates food Very Good and service and ambience Good.
Read original reviewParaphrased from Harden's 2026 diner-survey summary. Component scores are food 4/5, service 3/5 and ambience 3/5; these are not an overall rating.